Friday, December 23, 2011

Top 15: Readers' Favorite Tiaras


 I asked, you answered. Here are your Top 15 Favorite Tiaras:

 






















 







A little bit about the results: with 140+ tiaras suggested, the field was very wide and the votes were spread all over. Some made the list because they're just well-known overall, and others are a testament to the power of people reading and participating in the comment discussion, like Queen Victoria's Sapphire Coronet. A few things that surprised me:
  • The inclusion of the Cut Steel Tiara. If I had to guess which token "unusual" tiara would have made it, I would have gone with the Cameo Tiara - especially since it got a boost of publicity with Victoria's wedding in 2010. (And I was nearly right. The old Cameo popped in at #17.)
  • Speaking of wedding publicity, I'm surprised the Halo Scroll Tiara didn't have a very good showing. I thought the Power of Catherine would bump it higher than #71.
  • The tiara I am most surprised to see on your list is the Luxembourg Empire Tiara. Luxembourg's jewel collection is not very well-known, and the design itself can be overpowering for many (as proven by your comments!).
  • My other big surprise was how well the Rose Cut Diamond Bandeau did. As far as vote totals go, #1 and #2 absolutely ran away with it, and there for a while I thought we might even end up with the bandeau on top. In the end, though, the Girls won handily.

Now, because I'm terribly nosy, I'd love to know how this compared to your own list or to what you predicted before the countdown began. Did anything really surprise you? Do tell.


Next week, we'll have royal Christmas shenanigans to review and we'll start wrapping up the best and worst of the sartorial year. Until then, a very merry Christmas, happy Hanukkah, festive assorted other holidays, and a delightful weekend to you and yours!

Readers' Top 15 Tiaras: #1. The Girls of Great Britain & Ireland Tiara

And our countdown of your favorite tiaras ends with...

#1. The Girls of Great Britain and Ireland Tiara

Before I asked you to show me your favorite tiara, I showed you mine...and you agreed with me! Sweet, sweet validation. And I’m pretty sure Queen Elizabeth agrees with all of us, since this is her favorite tiara.
The Girls of Great Britain and Ireland Tiara, in its current form
This tiara was one of the future Queen Mary’s wedding presents in 1893, and you’ll never guess who gave it to her...the girls of Great Britain and Ireland. Specifically, a committee of them chaired by Lady Eve Greville (not the same lady as the Greville inheritance, mind you). The committee raised over £5,000 and purchased this tiara from Garrard before donating the remainder of the funds to charity at the request of the princess.
Queen Mary with the original version of the tiara (first and second on the left), just the bandeau, and her altered version of the piece
The tiara is a diamond design of festoons and scrolls set on a bandeau base of round and lozenge-shaped diamonds. It was originally topped with nine large pearl finials, and it could also originally be worn as a necklace. But you know Queen Mary, she never left her jewels alone, and so the original version did not stay put for long. In 1914, she removed the pearl finials and replaced them with simpler diamond collets; she also removed the base of the tiara and used it as a separate bandeau.

The tiara after Mary's alterations, as first received by Princess Elizabeth
In 1947, Mary gave the tiara to her granddaughter Princess Elizabeth as a wedding present, who is said to affectionately call it as “Granny’s tiara”. Right away, with tiara occasions coming back in vogue after the war, this became a frequently worn piece. Without the bandeau, it nestled right in with Elizabeth's never-changing hairstyle.
The tiara worn without the base
There's some mystery surrounding the separation of the bandeau base and the tiara itself. In this video (click here), around 9:15 you can hear Elizabeth talk about the tiara, and she indicates that she didn’t know the tiara had a base until after Queen Mary’s death in 1953. However, the bandeau can be seen displayed separately in the public viewing of the couple’s wedding gifts at St. James Palace. Perhaps she just meant that she didn’t know they were intended to go together?
With the base added
Anyway, with her new tiara knowledge in hand, Queen Elizabeth paired up the bandeau and the tiara once again. She made the change in 1969, and it’s been the same ever since. Though she'd already been queen for some time when she added it back in, it seems a fitting queenly makeover. A little extra height for the boost in position, maybe. 
This is known to be a very light tiara; it must also be fairly easy and comfortable to wear, with no pendants clanging about or anything like that. It's certainly easy to put on, or perhaps she's just practiced at it - Queen Elizabeth does her own tiara attachment. Factor in the sentiment behind a wedding gift from a beloved relative, plus the fact that it's one of the first tiaras she ever wore, and you've got the one diadem that the Queen pulls out more than any other. (And if you're trying to figure out how this got to be #1, don't forget: that means this is automatically one of the most famous tiaras in the world.) I have declared this in the past to be the most perfect tiara ever, and I stand firmly by my assessment. Why do I love this tiara? Let me count the ways...
Here you can see the dimension in the settings of the diamonds, which helps to catch light from every angle
It's all diamond (at least it is now), so that makes it nice and all purpose. It’s classically pretty - no real experimentation going on here, which tickles my particular fancy at least. And I think the design makes it easy to pair with a variety of styles of other jewelry (necklaces, etc.).
In motion
It’s big enough to say “I’m the Queen!” without screaming it loudly over every other aspect of one’s outfit. It’s also sizeable but light, which is always good for pretending it’s in your own collection (don’t pretend I’m the only one doing that, I know what your game is). And it’s sparkly. Oh, so sparkly. What more could you ask for?

Does this top your personal list?

Tomorrow: I will have a recap of the full Top 15. I'm eager to hear your thoughts on the countdown as a whole; until then, do enjoy your #1 gem.

Photos: Telegraph/Royal Collection/Leslie Field/Getty Images/Corbis

Readers' Top 15 Tiaras: #2. The Rose Cut Diamond Bandeau

Our countdown of your favorite tiaras continues with...

#2. The Rose Cut Diamond Bandeau 


I told you when we first covered this tiara that it would make my desert island list of five essential tiaras. As it turns out, we’d all have to be on the same island. (Though something tells me we’d never get it out of Máxima’s hands to take it on our three hour tour in the first place.) In a competition that ended up favoring the “go big or go home” rule, I love that you made sure to give this one a special pass for its own brand of going big. Incidentally, this is also the only diadem that came anywhere close to giving our #1 tiara some competition.

Are you surprised at where this fell on our countdown list?

Week in Review: Princess Máxima, 11-17 December

Here's what Máxima wore from 11-17 December:

  1. At the Prince Claus Awards, 14 December. Yay! The amazing purple dress makes a triumphant return.
Photo: Gala

Thursday, December 22, 2011

Readers' Top 15 Tiaras: #3. The Fife Tiara

Our countdown of your favorite tiaras continues with...

#3. The Fife Tiara

Coming in at number three, we have a tiara that hasn't been seen in public for a long, long time. And unless following the many and varied descendants of Queen Victoria is a personal hobby of yours, there's a good chance you're not that familiar with its wearers. But never mind that. Just loooook at it:
The Fife Tiara
The Fife Tiara is the third tiara on your list to hail from a noble family, but this time we have a royal beginning. It first belonged to Princess Louise of Wales, the oldest daughter of King Edward VII and Queen Alexandra. When she married the Earl of Fife in 1889, she received quite a waterfall of sparkling presents; this stunning tiara with pear-shaped diamonds hanging freely in a diamond framework, topped with more pear-shaped diamonds alternating with round diamonds, was among them. It is thought to be the work of Parisian jeweler Oscar Massin. This is sometimes said to have been a gift from her parents, but contemporary reporting of her wedding gifts attributed it to the Earl (who was made the Duke of Fife by Queen Victoria right after the wedding). Her parents' gift, on the other hand, is described as a classic convertible diamond fringe tiara.
Princess Louise, the Princess Royal and Duchess of Fife
Poor Louise is something of a background figure in royal history. She wasn't as pretty as her mother or her sister, Victoria, and she wasn't as notably married as her sister Queen Maud of Norway. Apparently a rather difficult person to make conversation with, she earned herself the title "Her Royal Shyness" and was most known for her talents in the realms of music and fishing. Her marriage to the Duke, who was 18 years older, seems to have done her a world of good - as, no doubt, did the escape from the smothering atmosphere of her parents' home. She was one of the first princesses to marry a subject rather than a prince but Queen Victoria approved of the union, noting that the groom was extremely rich.
Princess Louise
Louise was given the title of Princess Royal, but didn't play a large role in the royal family. Her ill health was a continual problem, and she escaped to warmer climates each winter. While en route to Egypt for the winter of 1911, the Fife family was shipwrecked off the coast of Morocco. Though they all survived, the ordeal took a toll on the Duke's health, and he passed away the following month.
The Duchess of Fife (left - wearing the Fife Tiara and the fringe tiara from her parents around her neck) and Queen Alexandra (right - wearing the kokoshnik tiara now worn by Queen Elizabeth) with Alexandra's mother, Queen Louise of Denmark (center)
Louise had three children: a stillborn son followed by two daughters, Alexandra and Maud. Because it was known in advance that there would be no Fife son to inherit the title, Queen Victoria made a special dispensation for inheritance in the female line. Accordingly, Princess Alexandra became the Duchess of Fife in her own right when her father died. Later she was also known as Princess Arthur of Connaught through her marriage. As she was predeceased by her own son, the title passed down to her nephew, James Carnegie. So far as we know, the tiara is still with the family.
Princess Alexandra, Duchess of Fife
Tiara occasions for the Fifes are very rare, which is terribly sad for us jewel lovers. This one in movement would be absolutely spectacular. Mounted in gold and set in silver, the largest diamonds freely articulate inside their diamond arches. That means that they would tremble with the tiniest movement of the wearer's head, capturing and reflecting the light constantly.
Caroline, Countess of Southesk, daughter-in-law of the current Duke
This has always been a favorite of mine. It has enormous individual stones and the design is very spiky, like a Gothic fence of some sort (the prettiest Gothic fence ever). And yet, I think delicate is a perfectly applicable word to describe it. That's what's remarkable about this, what makes it a triumph of workmanship and design, really: it retains a certain lightness despite the staggering carat weight on display.
Quite frankly, I find it breathtaking - especially at first glance. I'm not at all surprised that this made it so high on the list, even with a low-key history and essentially no contemporary outings and no well-known wearers.

Did you know about this tiara prior to our little voting extravaganza, or are you a new convert?

Photos: Geoffrey Munn/The Royal Collection

Week in Review: Princess Letizia, 11-17 December

Here's what Letizia wore from 11-17 December:

  1. Attending a lunch at the palace, 13 December.
  2. At a ceremony for the Prince of Girona Foundation, 14 December. Again with the strangely matched shoes. Why?
    We also got a glimpse of the family's Christmas card this week, prepare your awwws:
     

    Photos: Daylife/Getty Images

    Week in Review: Grand Duchess Maria Teresa, 11-17 December

    Here's what Maria Teresa wore from 11-17 December:

    1. The King's dinner for the Nobel laureates in Sweden, 11 December.
    2. Attending a requiem mass for the late Princess Elisabeth, 15 December.
    Photos: Bunte/Tom Wagner/Cour gr ducale